Tamako Market (+ Tamako Love Story)- Short Review

Good

Tamako Market is a very lighthearted comedy anime.  Though somewhat bland, perhaps it’s best to think of it as setting the stage for the OVA movie Tamako Love Story (Excellent).  Very sweet and fluffy, Tamako Market is about the joy of life – loving a peculiar little community.  If you love the super-sweet anime without any clouds in the sky, this is right up your alley.  If not, you can find it… trying.   That said, it doesn’t feel like much happens, in spite of the presence of a talking bird and the general main plotline of finding a bride for a foreign prince.  Actually, the talking bird is pretty much the saving grace of the show, acting as a refuge from the saccharine tone of the anime.

As much as I’d love to say skip ahead to Tamako Love Story, you really do need to finish Tamako Market because it develops the characters’ personalities and lays the framework for the OVA.

Tamako Love Story is a very different beast, and is more serious – it clouds over the sunshine a bit.   It’s about growing up and dealing with changes that happen in life, dealing with a combination of changes that you want to happen and changes that you are fighting against, even if subconsciously.  Everything about Tamako Love Story is stronger and more solid.  Come to think of it, the OVA has one of the strongest “confession” scenes in recent memory.  Really, this is the payoff that makes the whole series worth it.

Purpose: Decent
Characters: Good
World: Good
Plot: Decent
Storytelling: Decent
Pace: Decent

Advertisements

Gate – Short Review

Excellent

This was an anime I’ve wanted to see for some time.  I was expecting a rather campy show that followed in the line of “modern man goes to fantasy world” that we see fairly often.  Instead, it’s a very solid “what if” scenario that is well grounded in the vein of Log Horizon.  Essentially, it’s a more realistic depiction of a clash of worlds that includes light politics alongside particularly “cool” combat sequences.  Part of what makes it stand out is how well they develop the cast – everyone’s a professional and actually good at their jobs.  There’s a maturity to all of the dealings that is really refreshing – characters don’t fly off the handle “just because.”

The world is managed in a really strong fashion.  For example, in sequences that required interpreting between languages, it was handled in Japanese but they’d give cues that the language was different, like using really over-emphasized simple Japanese or to occasionally have the translator chime in. Moreover, the conflict is a conflict of people – someone may be doing villanous acts, but ultimately not a “villain,” as most stories will select someone and give them no redeeming qualities.

Another really fascinating thing the anime did was reinforce that our main character is an important part of the goings-on, but by no means the only actor on the field.  There’s a lot more at play, even when it affects our main character.  Sometimes, it will even leave our main group to follow someone else who is playing an important role in the issue.

All told, a really fun watch that has a strong balance of serious, silly, and cool.

Purpose: Very Good
Characters: Very Good
World: Excellent
Plot: Very Good
Storytelling: Excellent
Pace: Very Good